Problems with listed subnets and opsb/neostats or bopm
From: Sven Michels <smichels_at_domain.invalid>
Date: Mon 05 Jun 2006 - 22:47:33 CEST
Date: Mon 05 Jun 2006 - 22:47:33 CEST
Hi folks, once again, since this seems to be a growing problem, a few words on the subnet listing: Yes, we list every /24 (aka "class-c") which contains a tor node, too. And yes, this may lead to false positives, but: we do *not* recommend to use the subnet listing to block users! See www.sectoor.de/tor.php: Warning: the /24 listing of subnets containing a tor node isn't usefull for direct blocking users. Use this only for "scoring" or to alert you when a connect comes from a subnet which contains a tor node. If you use the subnet listing for banning people from your service, expect false positives! Then another problem showed up: OPSB from neostats doesn't support reply types for dns blacklists at all. This first popped up on rizon and we reported it to the neostats staff. Since implementing reply type checking was not a quick solution, we set up a new subzone which contains only tor nodes itself. This change was commited to opsb cvs the same day and we thought they'll release it quickly, but they didn't. So, for everyone who runs software which isn't able to check the reply type, please use: exitnodes.tor.dnsbl.sectoor.de instead. If you have any questions, feel free to ask. Thanks and have a nice week! Regards, Sven Michels PS: there is an ongoing problem with the subnet listing because of the new ip irc.netsplit.de uses to gather its statistics. So please check if you're affected and change your configs, otherwise netsplit cannot get statistics for your irc network! If you know affected networks, please point them to this posting (will be on webarchive, too). -- sectoor GmbH - Sven Michels <*> eMail: smichels(at)sectoor.de Geschaeftsfuehrer / CEO <*> Web : http://www.sectoor.de Huehnerweg 18 <*> Tel : +49 (0)69 9637 6000 D - 60599 Frankfurt am Main <*> Fax : +49 (0)69 9637 6006Received on Mon, 05 Jun 2006 22:47:33 +0200
